Free standard shipping on all orders over $100.
Shop Now

Free standard shipping on orders over $100. Shop Now

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Don't know where to start?

All Charms

A small red evil eye pendant with a white center and gold bail, displayed inside a square wooden shadow box on a light marble surface.

Orange Evil Eye Charm

$27.00

Unit price
per 

2 colors
  • Blue
  • Orange
A small evil eye pendant with a blue and white circular design and a gold bail, displayed inside a square light wood shadow box on a white and gray marble surface.
Sold out

Navy Evil Eye Charm

$27.00

Unit price
per 

2 colors
  • Blue
  • Orange
A small round gold pendant with a turquoise blue center, displayed inside a square light wood shadow box on a gray and white marble surface.

Turquoise Evil Eye Coin Charm

$27.00

Unit price
per 

Vintage Orange Teeny Tiny Wiggle Fish
Vintage

Vintage Orange Teeny Tiny Wiggle Fish

$85.00

Unit price
per 

A small fish-shaped enamel charm with red, orange, white, and black detailing rests inside an olive green velvet jewelry box on a light beige fabric surface.
A set of nine colorful fish-shaped jewelry charms or pendants arranged on a textured white fabric surface. The fish designs feature intricate enamel detailing in blue, green, red, orange, and gold, with some pieces showing scales and others displaying abstract patterns.
Vintage

Vintage Cloisonné Clownfish Charm

$145.00

Unit price
per 

A small polished brown and amber bird-shaped pendant or charm displayed inside an olive green octagonal jewelry box on a light neutral surface.

Tropical Parrot Charm

$98.00

Unit price
per 

A small mother of pearl fish pendant or charm with a pear-shaped outline and a small floral detail at the top, displayed in the center of an olive green velvet jewelry tray on a light beige fabric surface.
Vintage

Vintage Mother of Pearl Fish Pendant

$285.00

Unit price
per 

A small fish-shaped jewelry piece with blue and gold detailing, displayed on an olive green velvet jewelry tray over a light beige textured card on a marble surface.
Person wearing a white shirt and blue jeans with layered necklaces, including a green beaded necklace and a gold chain with a blue pendant.

Found Florentine Mosaic Fish

$145.00

Unit price
per 

A small fish-shaped pendant with red, orange, and white enamel details and a gold-tone ring at the top, displayed inside an olive green velvet jewelry box on a light beige textured surface.
Sold out

1960s Orange Wiggle Fish

$145.00

Unit price
per 

A small fish-shaped jewelry charm with blue, gold, and white enamel details, displayed inside an olive green velvet jewelry box on a light beige fabric surface.
Vintage

1960s Light Blue Wiggle Fish

$145.00

Unit price
per 

A small fish-shaped enamel pendant with blue, white, and gold detailing, displayed inside an olive green velvet jewelry box on a light beige surface.
Vintage

Found Blue Shiny Wiggle Fish

$155.00

Unit price
per 

A small decorative fish-shaped pendant or charm with gold, orange, and dark detailing, displayed inside an olive green octagonal tray on a light textured surface.
Sold out

Found Painted Wiggle Fish

$189.00

Unit price
per 

A small fish-shaped jewelry charm with gold and white scales, displayed inside an olive green velvet-lined octagonal tray on a light beige textured surface.
Best Seller

1960s White Wiggle Fish

$185.00

Unit price
per 

A small gold fish-shaped brooch or pin displayed in the center of an olive green octagonal velvet jewelry box, set against a light beige linen background.

Found Gold Wiggle Fish

$189.00

Unit price
per 

Green Big Guy Wiggle Fish Charm

Green Big Guy Wiggle Fish Charm

$175.00

Unit price
per 

Blue Big Guy Wiggle Fish Charm

Blue Big Guy Wiggle Fish Charm

$175.00

Unit price
per 

Collection of vintage fishing lures on a green tray with a striped background
Decorative parrot pendant on a green tray with a striped fabric background

Summer Charm Tray #1

from $27.00

Unit price
per 

handprinted pink heart pendant on a white surface
Collection of colorful heart-shaped charms on a marble background

Pink Fluer Heart Charm x Sara Joy

$98.00

Unit price
per 

hand painted moon pendant with chain on white background
Necklace with a blue eye charm on a gray card, framed by a striped fabric border.

Moon and Stars Charm x Sara Joy

$98.00

Unit price
per 

Gold chain bracelet with a pink heart charm on a white card against a marble background
Collection of colorful heart-shaped charms on a marble background

Fushia 444 Heart Charm x Sara Joy

$58.00

Unit price
per 

Necklace with a blue heart-shaped pendant on a marble background
Necklace with a blue heart-shaped pendant on a marble surface
Gold heart-shaped pendant necklace on a white card with a marble background
Gold heart-shaped pendant necklace on a white card with marble background

Large LOVE Puff Heart Charm x Sara Joy

$68.00

Unit price
per 

Gold chain necklace with a flower pendant on a white card against a marble background
Collection of colorful heart-shaped charms on a marble background

Dot Flower Charm x Sara Joy

$56.00

Unit price
per 

Gold necklace with a blue pendant on a white card against a marble background
Collection of colorful heart-shaped charms on a marble background

Blue Star Heart Charm x Sara Joy

$58.00

Unit price
per 

Heart-shaped pendant necklace on a white card with a marble background
Collection of colorful heart-shaped charms on a marble background

Space Heart Charm x Sara Joy

$68.00

Unit price
per 

Pink LOVE Heart Charm x Sara Joy
Collection of colorful heart-shaped charms on a marble background

Pink LOVE Heart Charm x Sara Joy

$68.00

Unit price
per 

White Heart Charm x Sara Joy
Collection of colorful heart-shaped charms on a marble background

White Heart Charm x Sara Joy

$58.00

Unit price
per 

Gold chain necklace with a hand painted 11:11 purple heart pendant on a marble background
Collection of colorful heart-shaped charms on a marble background

Lavender Puff Heart Charm x Sara Joy

$58.00

Unit price
per 

My Heart Charm

My Heart Charm

$27.00

Unit price
per 

Vintage Sterling K Locket
Vintage

Vintage Sterling K Locket

$125.00

Unit price
per 

Found Blue Lapis Heart

Found Blue Lapis Heart

$56.00

Unit price
per 

Vintage Victorian Cameo Charm
Vintage

Vintage Victorian Cameo Charm

$265.00

Unit price
per 

Found White Natural Shell

Found White Natural Shell

$48.00

Unit price
per 

Vintage Cloisonne Elephant Pendant
Vintage

Vintage Cloisonne Elephant Pendant

$158.00

Unit price
per 

Found Natural Shell
Sold out

Found Natural Shell

$48.00

Unit price
per 

A Martha's Vineyard Treasure
Vintage

A Martha's Vineyard Treasure

$347.00

Unit price
per 

All of The Love White Charm

All of The Love White Charm

$27.00

Unit price
per 

All of The Love Pink Charm

All of The Love Pink Charm

$27.00

Unit price
per 

A small gold fish-shaped pendant with a blue stone accent, displayed on top of an olive green velvet jewelry box against a light gray background.
A close-up of a person wearing a red and white geometric patterned button-up shirt with layered silver necklaces and light blue denim jeans.

Grecian Fish

$27.00

Unit price
per 

Old Salt Charm
A gold-tone charm necklace featuring a round colorful medallion, a clam shell, a small gold fish, and a larger white shell, displayed on a navy blue book with a gold seashell illustration.
New

Old Salt Charm

$58.00

Unit price
per